PhD defense Ugo Rabenjamina: Orchestrating Without Authority: Artifacts and Collective Representations in Innovation Ecosystems
Université Paris Cité, site Necker (salle des thèses, 160 rue de Vaugirard, F-75015 Paris)
Original title: Orchestrer sans autorité : artefacts et représentations collectives dans les écosystèmes d’innovation
Jury
- Cécile AYERBE, Professor, Université Côte d’Azur, France (Reviewer)
- Albéric TELLIER, Professor, Université Paris Dauphine-PSL, France (Reviewer)
- Patrick COHENDET, Professor, HEC Montréal, Canada (Examiner)
- Sébastien TRAN, Professor, Audencia, France (Examiner)
- Mathias BÉJEAN, Professor, École polytechnique, France (Examiner)
- Valérie FERNANDEZ, Professor, Télécom Paris, France (Thesis Supervisor)
- Thomas HOUY, Associate Professor (HDR), Télécom Paris, France (Thesis Co-supervisor)
Abstract
Getting actors to work together when they cannot be commanded is the central challenge of innovation ecosystems. Firms, startups, universities, and intermediaries are interdependent while remaining legally autonomous. The orchestrator must therefore align them without being able to impose a course of action. The literature explains how to coordinate their activities, facilitate knowledge flows, and organize value sharing. It sheds less light on what makes these dynamics possible in the first place: how actors make sense of the ecosystem to which they are expected to contribute.
This thesis argues that artifacts do more than coordinate action: they also contribute to making the ecosystem intelligible, which may foster participant engagement.
Through three studies, the thesis examines how artifacts contribute to making innovation ecosystems comprehensible. A digital platform makes an organization’s partners visible; value propositions give shape to an emerging and still uncertain technological category; a measurement instrument specifies the dimensions along which the state of an ecosystem can be assessed. These three objects correspond to three modes of representation: relational, categorical and evaluative.
The thesis proposes that orchestrating without authority is not merely a matter of coordinating action; it also involves making the ecosystem intelligible, a condition that may foster the engagement of autonomous actors. It thus identifies a representational function of artifacts, distinct from their coordinating function.